Melissa Kammer at NovelTalk
“Tawny Weber sizzles with this sexy tale. She takes us to a whole new level where the masks are bound to come off, and we are able to see what is lurking underneath. Zoe and Dex are quite an enticing pair, and it is fun to watch the dynamics between the two. The passion is fairly stifling, and we have a front row seat to the unavoidable and amazing climax. The remaining characters transport us back to high school days and add to the authenticity of the story. I must admit that I absolutely adored Dex’s grandmother, and she keeps everyone on his or her toes. Ms. Weber has once again crafted an alluring romance and a fabulous read. FEELS LIKE THE FIRST TIME ignites a well-fed fire, and the heat just keeps us coming back for more.”

4.5 Stars – CataRomance
“A book by Tawny Weber is always a delight to read. Her description of Zoe’s feelings about her high school reunion was so realistic it brought back memories, making it easy to relate to Zoe’s ambivalent feelings as she entered into the week’s activities. Dex had certainly grown in to a sexy man with some wonderful attributes which Zoe had no problem admiring. Needless to say, so could the reader. Sexy, hot, intriguing as well as fun are all hallmarks of a Tawny Weber tale. Feels Like the First Time has all that and more.”

5 Roses – A Romance Review
“You have to love a heroine who walks into her high school reunion wearing a dominatrix costume. Take that you people who dubbed her “The Girl Most Likely to Die a Virgin”! Feels Like the First Time is scandalous fun for the voracious reader. The story moves quickly, smoothly, and with enough heat to burn your fingers as you turn the pages. There’s so much more about Feels Like the First Time than I have room to tell you. You’ll have to read it for yourself to see what I’m talking about. Ms. Weber’s first entry into Harlequin’s Dressed to Thrill miniseries is not to be missed.”

5 Hearts / Top Pick – Night Owl Romance
“I absolutely loved this novel by Ms. Weber. I really enjoyed getting to know Zoe and her family. The author did a masterful job of building the storyline up and I found myself anxiously waiting for Gandalf’s identity to be revealed. Along the way, I loved how Ms. Weber entwined plenty of twists and turns of events to keep my mouth watering for more. I hopelessly fell in love with Dex and was glad he and Zoe saw each other again after all these years have past. I was hoping that maybe something would spark between these two and that Dex could be the man Zoe was looking for all this time. I’m new to Ms. Weber’s writing, but after this story, I’m a definite fan now. I can’t help but eagerly await her next novel to be released!”